I took it to a another shop today (which was alot friendlier, so I will probably go there from now on) and they are bring it back to the OOB finish.
He is doing what cgeorg mentioned in the post above. He said he was going to take off the thin contaminated (something like that, he said the top layer was very dirty because I hadn't cleaned it for a while) layer and use abralon pads then
polish the surface back to what the OOB specs are.
Thanks for all the helpful feedback guys! I appreciate it.
Oh, I also got some regular
cleaner called "Extreme
cleaner" which they sell in little bottles for $7.99 and will refill for $5.99. It looks like simple green but has a different, stronger smell to it.
I got it since he said that the Clean n' Dull was fine to use but it will take off the
polish over time. He said it's best to just go with a regular
cleaner and nothing more.
Again, thanks for the help!